3PL vs leasing a warehouse: which one fits your freight

The short answer

Lease a warehouse when your volume is steady and high enough to keep the building full, or when you need special equipment and your own people on the floor. Use a 3PL when volume rises and falls, when you are new to the region, or when you do not want to hire a crew and equip a building.

Your inventory has outgrown the space you have. The back room is full, or a lease is up for renewal and the terms have changed. The choice in front of you is 3PL vs leasing a warehouse: pay a third-party warehouse by the pallet, or sign for a building and run it yourself. Both work. The difference comes down to who carries the fixed costs.

Who pays for what

When you lease, you pay for the building and everything it takes to run it. When you use a 3PL, the same costs exist, but they sit inside a rate per pallet or per order.

Cost When you lease When you use a 3PL
Rent You pay every month, full or empty, plus property taxes, building insurance and maintenance under most leases Inside the storage rate. You pay for the pallet positions you use
Labor You hire, train and schedule the crew, and cover sick days and turnover The warehouse staffs the floor. You pay per pallet received and per order picked
Racking You buy it, install it and often need a permit for it Already standing in the building
Forklifts You buy or lease them, maintain them and train the operators The warehouse supplies them
Utilities Your bill Inside the rates
Systems You buy inventory software and scanners and set them up The warehouse’s system tracks your stock and sends you reports
Insurance You insure your goods and the operation The warehouse insures its operation. You usually still insure your goods

Nothing in the right-hand column is free. You pay for all of it through the rates. The difference is that the cost moves with your volume instead of sitting still.

Published market ranges for greater Seattle run $18 to $25 per pallet per month for storage, $5 to $15 per pallet for receiving and $2 to $3 per order for pick and pack. These are market ranges, not our quote. More on each fee is on the pricing page.

How long you are committed

A warehouse lease usually runs for several years. You sign for a fixed amount of space on the first day, and you owe rent on it until the last. Leaving early usually means finding a subtenant or negotiating with the landlord.

A 3PL agreement is usually far shorter. Many run month to month. Storage arranged through Seattle 3PL is month to month, and you pay for the pallet positions you use. With any 3PL, read the notice period and the monthly minimum before you sign.

What happens when volume changes

  • Volume drops. Under a lease the rent stays the same, and the empty floor is yours to pay for. Under a 3PL the storage bill falls with the pallet count.
  • Volume jumps. Under a lease you run out of floor, and more floor means another lease or a search for overflow warehousing. Under a 3PL you send more pallets and pay for more positions, as long as the building has room. Ask about room before peak season, not during it.
  • Volume is seasonal. A lease has to be sized for the busiest month, so you pay for peak space all year. A 3PL bills the peak only while it lasts.

How much control you keep

A leased building is yours to run. Your people work the floor. You set the hours, the pick method and the packing standard. You can walk in at any hour and look at your stock.

A 3PL runs its own process. You send orders and releases, and the warehouse works them in its system, on its schedule, with its cutoff times. You see your inventory through reports. If something goes wrong, you file a claim. You cannot walk over and fix it yourself.

When leasing is the right call

Leasing wins in three cases.

  • Your volume is steady and high. If you can keep a building full all year, you stop paying a 3PL’s margin on space and labor.
  • You need special equipment. Production lines, custom racking, cranes or anything bolted to the floor belongs in a building you control.
  • You want your own people on the floor. Some products need staff who know them well, and some companies want the warehouse to be part of the business.

In each case, be sure of the forecast. A lease rewards you for being right about the next several years and charges you for being wrong.

When a 3PL is the right call

A 3PL wins when the future is hard to predict.

  • Your volume rises and falls with the season or with container arrivals.
  • You are entering the Pacific Northwest from another state and do not know yet how much stock the region needs.
  • You would rather put cash into inventory than into racking, forklifts and deposits.
  • You do not want to recruit and manage a warehouse crew.

Many shippers do both. They lease for the base volume they are sure of and send the peak to pallet storage by the month.

How to compare the two on paper

  1. Count your pallets in the slowest month and the busiest month.
  2. For the lease, ask a commercial broker for current rates on space sized for the busiest month. Add the lease’s taxes, insurance and maintenance charges. Then add labor, racking, forklifts, utilities and systems.
  3. For the 3PL, multiply your pallet count for each month by the quoted storage rate. Add receiving for every inbound pallet and pick and pack for every order.
  4. Compare the totals over the full lease term, not over one month.

The pallet storage cost estimator does step 3 for storage and receiving with the market ranges. For the lease side, how warehouse space is priced in Seattle walks through each charge.

Get the 3PL number first

The 3PL side of the comparison is the quick one to pin down. Send your pallet count, dimensions, weight and how long the freight will stay. Ask for a quote and you get rates within one business day. Then you have a real figure to set against the broker’s lease numbers. If freight is arriving this week, call (419) 745-9492 instead of writing.

Questions

3PL vs leasing a warehouse: which costs less?

A 3PL usually costs less when your space would sit partly empty for part of the year, and a lease usually costs less when you keep a building full all year. The lease has fixed costs that do not fall with volume. Compare both over the full lease term, using your slowest and busiest months.

What do I still handle myself when I use a 3PL?

You still buy and own the inventory, tell the warehouse what is arriving, send orders or releases, and insure your goods. The warehouse does the receiving, storage, picking and loading.

How quickly can I start with a 3PL compared with a lease?

A 3PL can usually take freight much sooner than a leased building, because the racking, equipment and crew are already in place. A lease needs a search, a negotiation, racking, equipment and hiring before the first pallet arrives. Ask the 3PL for its earliest receiving appointment.

Can I switch from a 3PL to my own warehouse later?

Yes, and a month-to-month 3PL agreement makes the switch simple: you give notice and ship the inventory out. A year of 3PL invoices also shows your real pallet counts, which makes sizing a lease far less of a guess.

Keep reading

Request a quote

You get a written quote within one business day. Tell us what the freight is, how much there is and when it arrives. The more exact the details, the more exact the number.

Freight arriving this week? Call (419) 745-9492. A call is answered before an email.

Or write to operations@sams3pl.com.

Get a quoteCall